The healthcare industry is undergoing rapid transformation, propelled by innovation in technology and evolving patient demands. However, this evolution comes with its own set of challenges. Insights from global markets, particularly the U.S., U.K., and Singapore, highlight critical issues such as nuclear verdicts, batch claims, cybersecurity risks, and the integration of artificial intelligence (AI). Here's how healthcare providers can address these emerging risks.
1. Escalating Legal Risks: Nuclear Verdicts and Batch Claims
Healthcare providers are increasingly facing "nuclear verdicts" — lawsuits with settlements, including legal fees, that exceed $10 million, particularly in complex batch claims. In the U.S., a notable example is a $183 million verdict due to delayed care, demonstrating how jury trials often result in excessively large payouts. This trend is fuelled by:
Social Inflation: Public perception of "normal" compensation has shifted due to societal narratives and exposure to large monetary figures in media.
Third-Party Litigation Funding: Private equity firms fund lawsuits, incentivizing attorneys to pursue massive settlements.
Post-COVID Sentiment: For-profit healthcare organizations face heightened scrutiny, resulting in punitive damages.
Additionally, batch claims — where a single incident impacts multiple patients — pose significant risks. For example, a procedural error in Singapore could affect 20–30 patients, amplifying liabilities.
Mitigation Tactics:
Strengthen risk management protocols.
Conduct thorough reviews of patient safety practices.
Regularly assess policy limits: Stay informed about any changes in the judicial system, including awarded damages, and remain vigilant regarding potential batch claims and “nuclear verdict” exposure.
Note: “Nuclear Verdict” exposure is particularly prevalent in the USA due to third-party funded liability claims, where a “no win no pay” system is practiced. This practice is not permitted in Singapore.
2. AI and Robotics: Progress and Perils
The adoption of AI and robotics in healthcare is transforming diagnostics, surgery, and patient monitoring. However, these technologies introduce new risks:
AI Errors: Misdiagnoses due to flawed data.
Robotic Malfunctions: Liability concerns if equipment fails or is misused.
Policy Gaps: Lack of clarity on whether AI claims fall under cyber insurance, medical malpractice, or both.
Mitigation Tactics:
Work with experienced insurance brokers to update policies specific to AI risks.
Maintain human oversight in AI-driven processes.
Invest in training staff to safely and effectively use these technologies.
3. Cybersecurity: Protecting Patient Data
The healthcare sector is a prime target for cyberattacks, including ransomware and data breaches. For example, in the US, cyberattacks tripled after geopolitical tensions, disrupting healthcare operations and compromising patient records.
Mitigation Tactics:
Implement robust cybersecurity measures, including regular audits.
Obtain cyber insurance tailored to healthcare operations.
Train staff to recognize and prevent cyber threats.
4. Reputation and Communication: The Value of Empathy
Poor communication after incidents can escalate claims and damage reputations. In Singapore, training doctors to express empathy using appropriate language has significantly reduced claims. Patients often value acknowledgment of their concerns over financial compensation.
Mitigation Tactics:
Train staff on effective communication and empathy.
Establish protocols for managing patient complaints promptly.
Focus on transparency and patient engagement.
5. Increasing Business Collaborations / Service & Equipment Procurements
Healthcare organisations are increasingly engaged in research activities aimed at developing new pharmaceutical products, medical devices, and procedures. In these instances, it is essential to conduct a separate risk review and assess insurance policy coverage to ensure effective risk transfer to insurance companies.
Mitigation Tactics:
Contractual obligations / Indemnity Clause: Carefully review and enforce contracts to hold third-party collaborators and suppliers accountable for potential claims from third parties, such as serious adverse injuries sustained by trial subjects or failure related to equipment and services.
Engagement of Experienced Insurance Broker: Consult with a knowledgeable insurance broker to evaluate coverage options and enhance risk management strategies.
Explore Clinical Trials Insurance: Investigate options for clinical trials insurance in the global market to ensure comprehensive coverage and effective claims management capabilities.
6. Credentialing and HR Risks
Credentialing failures and inadequate employee vetting can lead to misconduct or negligence. For example, cases of sexual misconduct in nursing homes have resulted in severe legal and reputational consequences.
Mitigation Tactics:
Conduct rigorous background checks and credentialing.
Ensure proper supervision and training for all staff.
Review and enforce contracts to hold third-party suppliers accountable for equipment or service failures.
7. Cultural Sensitivity in Healthcare
In multicultural environments like Singapore, the mismanagement of religious or cultural sensitivities — for example, the wrongful or improper release of deceased bodies — can lead to significant mental anguish and discomfort for the deceased’s family regarding their rightful religious rituals. The mismanagement may result in claims seeking compensation or damages.
Mitigation Tactics:
Staff Training: Provide training for staff to ensure they handle cases with cultural and religious awareness.
Clear Protocols: Develop and implement clear protocols for managing sensitive situations effectively.
8. Tailored Insurance Solutions
Given these emerging risks, healthcare organizations must work closely with brokers to ensure comprehensive coverage. Policies should address AI integration, cybersecurity, batch claims, and other unique challenges.
Key Considerations:
Assess policy wording to review ‘exclusions’ for emerging risks.
Benchmark coverage limits to ensure adequacy.
Regularly review and update policies as new risks emerge.
Conclusion
The future of healthcare lies in balancing innovation with careful risk management. From leveraging AI to addressing cybersecurity threats and legal risks, healthcare organizations must adopt proactive strategies to protect patients, staff, and their reputations. By learning from global markets and collaborating with insurers, they can navigate the complexities of a changing landscape and deliver safe, reliable care.
About Lockton Conversations:
Lockton Conversations is our dynamic series that fosters engaging dialogue and the exchange of best practices among senior stakeholders. These sessions empower businesses through insightful discussions. Stay tuned for our upcoming events, where we’ll continue to share thought-provoking insights and drive improvement across industries. Join us in shaping the future of business!
